It’s time once again to ask the question this website asks: What is it? Well, one things for sure – it’s not really Doom, but it comes pretty close.
Doom throws you into the action immediately – like the original. After a brief scene that makes absolutely no sense whatsoever (and hints at a really, really dumb twist about Doomguy) you are tossed into action shooting “possessed” (think zombie marines but shittier and without guns) in a brief battle that shows how insanely, boringly easy this game is going to be for the next n hours.
The level design just feels uninspired and…industrial. None of the levels have any of the charm of the original games and they are just so boring and lifeless. They may be aesthetically pretty – some of them anyway like this room – but it’s entirely skin deep. They are all so straightforward that it almost negates using colored keycards/skulls, because getting each of them is an effortless affair that only ever requires a simple trot down a hallway, and a punchfest with a few demons. On top of that, the game – because it is 3D – has platforming in it. Why is there platforming in my Doom? Why am I dropkick brutalizing demons? Yes, I’m aware there was elevation in Doom, but it was out of your control. The platforming only gets worse too, with the Argent Tower level being based entirely around platforming, and the levels gain a large degree of verticality to them once you get to Hell. There is literally an entire level of nothing but platforming (also some demons) which appears to only have been put in the game to justify the jump boots.
I play games like Far Cry or Dying Light or Mirror’s Edge if I want first person platforming. Don’t ever do this again.
Doom‘s soundtrack is pretty much non-existent and the only time I can remember hearing it was after the silly intro, where something half decent and almost resembling the amazing original MIDIs played. Compared to Brutal Doom mod, or even listening to IDKFA, I feel nothing positive about Mick Gordon’s soundtrack. On a positive note, once you get to hell the music definitely improves, but it doesn’t excuse the lack of music in the first 4 levels. Really, all I heard is Demon Hunter, like I’m playing KF2. To me, Demon Hunter is just dreadfully boring pseudo neo-stoner-metal. And even then it’s only after you kill a demon nest and fight off a wave that you hear any real music. There is no ambient level soundtrack a lot of the time.
For the first half of the game, new enemies are introduced in a bland, generic way where none of them are given any pomp and circumstance – they just happen to join the fray. I didn’t even realize the first time I was fighting a Hell Knight until I had already half killed him, and it only registered for a brief few seconds in my mind before he was dead anyway. Best of all, there are a lot of enemy types, so it’s just a constant repeat of “hmm what’s this random guy I haven’t seen this one I don’t think, oh he’s dead.” Until the Manccubus. Then almost every enemy afterwards gets special treatment. They put minimal personality in to the introduction of these enemies. The ONLY time that half of the game even had a little cutscene to say “OMG” was when you fight the first Mancubbus, and then immediately after that you are fighting Mancubbi all the time. Remember the first time you encountered a Pinky in Doom 3? It was scary and it was awesome. In this game, the System Shock 2 hologram junk shows you what a Pinky looks like long before you ever see one. Sidenote: They are somehow stronger enemies than all new enemies introduced until that point. Pinkys, the guys who took 3 shotgun hits to kill, are stronger than Barons.
They have definitely put in effort to making the game an actual Doom game as opposed to Doom 3.The fact that enemies are three dimensional combined with the fact that they actually move around and try to flank you makes it interesting, but combat becomes thoroughly mindless and just… boring less than halfway through the game. Glory killing everything to death is too easy and far too likely for you to become overreliant upon, especially with enemies that are otherwise bullet sponges. It basically negates the entire point of Doom to have this feature be so powerful, because the weapons are boring and not fun to use and more often than not, they serve no purpose but to weaken an enemy so you can instakill them. In fact that’s even one of the Rune challenges. The weapons still feel like they have no weight or umph to them, just like in the multiplayer beta. By the way, this game literally has the Halo plasma pistol in it. It may be a different model and fire different colored plasma, but it is the exact same gun. Right click to charge fire a powerful shot left click to spam. The only difference is it has infinite ammo.
However, these screenshots will always be the only proper Doom:
To exacerbate that, it doesn’t feel like enemies are any threat to you either. The only enemies that ever concern me are Hell Knights and it’s only because they are fast and follow you around with a ground pound attack – even Barons are harmless. Summoners? Don’t care. Manccubi? Too slow to matter. Revenants? Lol, so easy to kill. It doesn’t even feel like you’re in danger when Revenants rocket spam you – because you have the same tiny rocket launcher and it’s a piece of trash – same applies to all the various projectile weapons demons and posessed toss at you. I played half the game before I died from an enemy and the only reason that happened is because I didn’t actually look where I was going and ended up running in to a laser. That was the one and only time I died in the entire game from an enemy. Every other death has been fall damage or from the BFG laser grid.
The graphics are pretty and the game is mostly well optimized. You can cry all you want about how Rage had a lot of memory issues because of textures, and how those same issues persisted in The New Order (you’re wrong if you do), but this game runs just fine. When it runs. I did not have any issues until Hell on Mars and then my FPS flatlined at like 12 frames, for no discernible reason. My GPU wasn’t overheating, my CPU wasn’t overheating, my SSD wasn’t overheating and nothing else was running. This was on a 750TI with a Lynnfield I7 and DDR3 memory. On my GTX1080 with a Skylake I7 and DDR4, the game runs at 200 fps no problem.
The effects look pretty cool from the explosions and the glowing magma to the red dust storms on the planets surface. It all still looks generic and clay, though, like Doom 3 did. The only difference is they learned how bump mapping and specular mapping works so now it’s not as bad. On top of that, the physics in the game are inconsistent and decide when they exist. You can run directly into an object and it won’t move, but then run into the same object somewhere else and it goes flying. And of course, as with all modern games with physics, objects will move slightly and then get caught in an endless loop, making more noise and being more disconcerting than the enemies.
Should I even mention the story? Think Doom 3, but with a commune communitatis trope (so overused) underlying the completely absurd story. A story where Demons can evidently be captured like Pokemon, and Hell is accepted unquestionably as a physical place. A place being treated more like the rain forest or Iraq or something, rather than THE SCARIEST THING IMAGINABLE. Not only is the story terrible, but there’s too much of it, and the game too often forces you to remember there’s a bad story behind all the demon blood and explosions by wrestling control away from you in story moments when you activate a switch or grab a thing. Did I mention the really, really, really dumb twist about Doomguy? The one I hinted at?
Multiplayer? So bad. So unbalanced. Nothing has changed since beta except now people have BFGs and Manccubi. The god awful lag is still there. You’re still playing with people in a bunker underneath New Zealand who literally found a way to make string carry a phone signal. There still is no matchmaking balance whatsoever, resulting in teams of nobs with automatic rifles fighting people with BFGs and manccubis, and people who are simply on the other side of the planet. Something that literally should never ever be happening unless they are the *only* other people playing. PS It’s still Peer to Peer matchmaking, a lesson even Activision learned from.
I would not pay full price, but it’s definitely better than Doom 3.